Explore

Exuma’s Most Legendary Resort

badge

Peace and Plenty Resort, homepage

Two Resorts in One

Discover the romance and natural wonders of an authentic Bahamian Out Island vacation at The Peace & Plenty Resort on Great Exuma. Since 1958, a “Who’s Who” list of celebrities, A-list actors, and famous athletes have chosen our little out-of-the-way spot to escape from the spotlight and sink their feet in the sand. As the Caribbean Journal’s 2022 list of “The Coolest Caribbean Hotels” described, The Peace & Plenty combines “an historic, throwback waterside hotel and a private beach club on the jaw-dropping beaches of Stocking Island, just across the bay."

Sip your morning coffee overlooking the crystal-clear turquoise water from one of our many oceanfront guestrooms or choose one of our six charming island cottages across the bay on Stocking Island, just steps from our breathtaking beach club. Either way, whether it’s relaxation, a boating/fishing/diving adventure, or beach party you’re seeking, The Peace & Plenty offers a truly exotic tropical vacation much closer to home.

Peace & Plenty Resort

shore of the beach with crystal clear water, and beach chairs and umbrellas in front
pool with the pool chairs in front
map

Activities

  • Boating to nearby islands and sandbars
  • Swimming with turtles
  • Bonefishing and deep sea fishing
  • Snorkeling reefs and blue holes
  • Feed the famous Exuma swimming pigs
  • Cocktails on the beach
little kid holding a tall fishing rode next to the shore
image underwater of a lady snorkeling
close view of a swimming pig

Four Reasons You’ll Never Want To Leave

woman doing yoga exercise on a jet ski plenty trs image 1 pool area with the beach in front in a pink filter aerial view of the oceans with people in boats

An Exotic Beach Club

One

Go off the grid for the day at our calm water Beach Club on Stocking Island, a sun-drenched spot for dips in the ocean and a drink (or two) at the bar. Enjoy paddleboarding, kayaking, or snorkeling the reef just steps from our beach. 

dot dot dot dot
plenty trs image 1

Storied History

Two

We’ve welcomed Jimmy Buffett, Prince Philip, Jackie O, Johnny Depp, and many other island lovers over our 60+ years, but the site’s history extends much farther back than that...

Read more

Storied History

We’ve welcomed Jimmy Buffett, Prince Philip, Jackie O, Johnny Depp, and many other island lovers over our 60+ years, but the site’s history extends much farther back than that. Lord Denys Rolle sailed to Exuma in 1783 aboard the English trading ship Peace and Plenty. He established a cotton plantation, naming it after his ship. Nearly 200 years later, on January 14, 1958, Lawrence Lewis, the grandson of railroad tycoon Henry Flagler, opened the Peace & Plenty Hotel on the site. The old plantation cookhouse became the club’s bar, while the main lobby began as a sponge warehouse.

A group of experienced investors in partnership with a sophisticated hotel operator acquired the property in 2017, melding the tradition, culture, and feel of the original Peace & Plenty with a luxurious experience.

dot dot dot dot
pool area with the beach in front in a pink filter

Central Location

Three

We're the "launch pad" to Elizabeth Harbour where countless pristine white sand beaches, sand bars, and boating adventures await.

dot dot dot dot
aerial view of the oceans with people in boats

Aquatic Thrills

Four

Discover Exuma’s glorious tropical waters by paddleboard, kayak, or snorkel.

dot dot dot dot
woman doing yoga exercise on a jet ski
plenty dining plate

DINING

Eat and Drink, Boutique Island Style

Savor the freshest island flavors including new sushi bar at our restaurant, Copia, or pull up a chair at one of our two bars – The Flagler Room featuring live piano and an indescribable “x-factor” of history and character; and Doc’s Patio Bar majestically overlooking Elizabeth Harbour.

Peace & Plenty Rooms & Suites Island Cottages

Balconies of Blue

Located in the heart of Georgetown, the Peace & Plenty is the gateway to countless adventures on pristine Elizabeth Harbour.  Serene and island-chic, virtually all of our guest rooms have floor-to-ceiling direct or partial views of the turquoise ocean just below.

View Rooms & Suites

A Serene Island Retreat

Our five island cottages are just steps from the beach club and offer a truly unique, peaceful, and private island experience.

View Cottages
peaceandplenty rooms balconiesofblue
shore of the beach with crystal clear water, and beach chairs and umbrellas in front
tripadvisor 01

What Guests Love

“A little piece of paradise”

“This is our 5th visit in a year to this property. We just love coming here. The staff is so friendly and accommodating. The rooms are very clean and have a great view. The food is delicious. The water is about the nicest water I have seen. We love P&P!"

Lanettecueto on Tripadvisor

"Perfect Stay"

Our recent stay at Peace and Plenty was perfect. The location is right in downtown. The room had a perfect view of the water. The daily room service was exceptional. The boat service to Stocking Island was our favorite. The Beach Club really enhanced our stay. Beautiful island with paddle boards and kayaks. They serve great drinks!! We can't wait to return!!!! Peace & Plenty is the best.

Stephanie H on Tripadvisor

"Highly recommend"

“Our stay at Peace and Plenty was wonderful! Our accommodations were great, the staff was wonderful, and having access to Stocking Island was great! It's such a beautiful place! We highly recommend this spot if you're looking for a one stop vacation spot!!”

Tara G on Tripadvisor

Get to know

Great Exuma

Just 300 miles from Miami with direct flights from several US cities and boasting a sea in every imaginable shade of blue, Exuma is a true island paradise right next door.

inset map

Gallery